• 0 Posts
  • 68 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 1st, 2023

help-circle






  • Same with audiobooks. The “classic” way is to have several MP3 files - 1 for each chapter. This allows them to be played even on dumb MP3 players.

    However, the M4B format allows for more modern AAC and HE-AAC encoding and adds metadata such as chapters directly into the file. This results in the whole audiobook being contained in just one single file and with much better compression than MP3. But you’ll need a compatible player to listen to them.

    (I’ve transcoded most of my audiobooks to M4B as a collection of 320kbps Stereo MP3s doesn’t make sense for just spoken content.)








  • This is because they own the gameplay

    Do they, though? They create the world, but the player is the one controlling the action.

    someone reading a book out loud publicly

    If I publicly read a book, I replay the contents verbatim. Basically an exact copy. But playing a game IMHO is more like fan-fiction. I’m making my own story and thus there should be no way to get any legal case against showing/publishing this to others.

    That being said, if you monetise your videos and make money from them, it becomes a whole different story.




  • But how is it deemed illegal when Nintendo “loses” pre-release games in the wild and somebody “finds” it and shows it off on YouTube? Game reviewers are bound by NDAs and have contracts with Ninty - but these “criminals” don’t. So what’s the crime here? Publishing something Ninty didn’t want to get out yet? And how is this copyright infringement when he never stated that he’s made a Mario game? Or is trying to sell Mario-themed stuff? It’s an official game from Ninty, so what does this have to do with copyright? Where did he copy it?

    Same with the “circumvention” … if you can easily make a copy of the key from your own device - which you’ve legally bought and where you only need a paper clip to do it - what are you circumventing then? If you buy a lock, it usually comes with the keys on a keyring that’s “locked” to the loop. Is removing a key from that keyring also “circumventing” then?

    The big problem here is that most people doing law have no idea about the technical stuff. And until that changes we’ll see lots of these ridiculous claims going through.