Professional software engineer, musician, gamer, stoic, democratic socialist

  • 6 Posts
  • 137 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 2nd, 2023

help-circle








  • The main point of OP is that this was a misunderstanding that turned into an overreaction. It sounds like there was never any confusion among the maintainers that they were trying to create a policy to prevent LLM slop PRs and reduce maintenance burden. Somehow non-maintainers derailed the discussion into an anti-AI tirade that was completely unproductive.

    So basically: yes people should shut up if they don’t have anything productive to add to the discussion.


  • It was clear he was referring to anyone involving themselves unnecessarily in the business of maintainers trying to create a policy. This tends to happen whenever maintainers discuss things openly.

    It didn’t seem condescending to me. You have to accept that non-contributors simply don’t get as much weight as contributors in this kind of discussion. So when a lead maintainer sees non-contributors starting debates and criticizing the project when they don’t have their facts straight and it really wasn’t any of their business to begin with, they have a right to call them out.